Annex B. Indicators

B.1.1.1 Share of CHOs in a satisfactory technical condition in the total number of CHOs on the territory of the historic settlement; unit of measurement — %; level — C; target fields — ENV, AT; link to clauses — 6.2.7, 7.3.1, 12.2.4, item a); data source — CHO passports, technical condition reports, heritage protection authorities; periodicity — annually.

B.1.1.2 Share of CHOs in an unsatisfactory and emergency technical condition; unit of measurement — %; level — C; target fields — ENV, RES; link to clauses — 6.2.7, 12.2.4, item a); data source — CHO passports, technical condition reports; periodicity — annually.

B.1.1.3 Number of CHOs lost during the reporting period; unit of measurement — units; level — I; target fields — ENV; link to clauses — 12.2.4, item a), 12.4.1; data source — Unified state register of CHOs, heritage protection authorities; periodicity — annually.

B.1.1.4 Share of CHOs with an approved subject of protection; unit of measurement — %; level — O; target fields — ENV; link to clauses — 6.2.7, 7.3.6, 5.4.4, item c); data source — Unified state register of CHOs; periodicity — annually.

B.1.1.5 Share of CHOs with executed protection obligations; unit of measurement — %; level — O; target fields — ENV; link to clauses — 6.2.7, 12.2.4, item a); data source — heritage protection authorities; periodicity — annually.

B.1.1.6 Share of CHOs with a current technical condition report (not older than 5 years); unit of measurement — %; level — O; target fields — ENV; link to clauses — 6.2.7, 12.2.4, item a); data source — heritage protection authorities, CHO passports; periodicity — annually.

B.1.1.7 Share of CHOs with complete cadastral registration; unit of measurement — %; level — O; target fields — ENV; link to clauses — 6.2.7, 7.3.6; data source — Rosreestr, EGRN; periodicity — annually.

B.1.2.1 Authenticity index of the historic environment — an integral expert assessment by the parameters: form and design, materials and substance, use and function, traditions and techniques, location and setting, spirit and feeling of the place (method — B.3.2); unit of measurement — points (0–100); level — I; target fields — ENV, AT; link to clauses — 3.1.8, 6.2.4, 7.3.2, 12.2.4, item b), 12.4.2; data source — expert survey, assessment under 7.12; periodicity — once every 3–5 years.

B.1.2.2 Integrity index of the historic environment — an assessment of the wholeness and intactness of the elements necessary to express historical and cultural value (method — B.3.2); unit of measurement — points (0–100); level — I; target fields — ENV; link to clauses — 3.1.9, 6.2.4, 7.3.2, 12.2.4, item b), 12.4.2; data source — expert survey, assessment under 7.12; periodicity — once every 3–5 years.

B.1.2.3 Share of preserved elements of the historic planning structure (street and road network, blocks, squares, compositional axes); unit of measurement — %; level — C; target fields — ENV; link to clauses — 6.3.2, 7.4.1, 12.4.2; data source — GIS analysis, GISOGD, expert survey; periodicity — once every 3–5 years.

B.1.2.4 Share of preserved visual openings and panoramas in the total number recorded in the subject of protection; unit of measurement — %; level — C; target fields — ENV, AT; link to clauses — 6.3.3, 7.4.2; data source — GIS analysis, landscape and visual analysis; periodicity — once every 3–5 years.

B.1.2.5 Share of the area of dissonant development in the total area of the territory of the historic settlement; unit of measurement — %; level — C; target fields — ENV, AT; link to clauses — 7.4.3, 9.5.7; data source — GIS analysis, expert survey; periodicity — once every 3–5 years.

B.1.3.1 Share of preserved elements of the subject of protection assigned to the analytical group "historic built fabric"; unit of measurement — %; level — C; target fields — ENV; link to clauses — 6.2.3, 7.3.1, 12.2.4, item c); data source — expert survey, inventory data; periodicity — once every 3–5 years.

B.1.3.2 Share of preserved elements of the subject of protection assigned to the analytical group "planning structure"; unit of measurement — %; level — C; target fields — ENV; link to clauses — 6.2.3, 7.3.1, 12.2.4, item c); data source — GIS analysis, expert survey; periodicity — once every 3–5 years.

B.1.3.3 Share of preserved elements of the subject of protection assigned to the analytical group "natural elements and landscape"; unit of measurement — %; level — C; target fields — ENV, RUR; link to clauses — 6.2.3, 7.3.1, 12.2.4, item c); data source — GIS analysis, expert survey; periodicity — once every 3–5 years.

B.1.3.4 Share of preserved elements of the subject of protection assigned to the analytical group "visual links"; unit of measurement — %; level — C; target fields — ENV, AT; link to clauses — 6.2.3, 7.3.1, 7.4.2, 12.2.4, item c); data source — landscape and visual analysis; periodicity — once every 3–5 years.

B.1.3.5 Number of elements of the subject of protection with identified threats; unit of measurement — units; level — C; target fields — ENV, RES; link to clauses — 12.2.4, item c), 12.4.1, 12.4.4; data source — condition monitoring, expert survey; periodicity — annually.

B.1.3.6 Number of implemented measures for the regeneration of the historic environment over the period; unit of measurement — units; level — O; target fields — ENV, AT; link to clauses — 4.3.12, 5.4.4, item d), 9.5.2; data source — reporting of the project office; periodicity — annually.

B.1.3.7 Area of territories on which regeneration of the historic environment has been carried out; unit of measurement — ha; level — O; target fields — ENV; link to clauses — 4.3.12, 5.4.4, item d), 9.5.2; data source — GIS data, reporting of the project office; periodicity — annually.

B.1.4.1 Number of documented practices, crafts and traditions of intangible heritage; unit of measurement — units; level — C; target fields — ENV, SOC; link to clauses — 4.3.5, 5.4.4, item e), 6.2.5, 12.2.4, item d), 12.4.5; data source — register of intangible heritage, expert data; periodicity — annually.

B.1.4.2 Number of active bearers of intangible heritage; unit of measurement — persons; level — C; target fields — ENV, SOC; link to clauses — 4.3.5, 12.2.4, item d), 12.4.5; data source — surveys, data of NPOs and cultural institutions; periodicity — annually.

B.1.4.3 Number of educational and cultural programmes with the integration of intangible heritage; unit of measurement — units; level — O; target fields — SOC, WB; link to clauses — 4.3.5, 4.2.1, 12.2.4, item d); data source — data of educational and cultural institutions; periodicity — annually.

B.1.4.4 Use of the historical experience of the development of the territory in forming the brand (expert assessment of the presence and quality of the integration); unit of measurement — points (0–5); level — C; target fields — AT, SOC; link to clauses — 4.3.5, 4.4.3, 9.5.6, 12.4.5; data source — expert assessment, analysis of documentation; periodicity — once every 3–5 years.

B.1.5.1 Share of CHOs with prepared investment passports; unit of measurement — %; level — O; target fields — AT; link to clauses — 4.4.5, 5.4.4, item c), 9.5.3, 12.2.4, item e); data source — reporting of the project office, information system; periodicity — annually.

B.1.5.2 Share of CHOs with complete record documentation (subject of protection, cadastral data, protection obligations, technical condition report, information on encumbrances); unit of measurement — %; level — O; target fields — AT, ENV; link to clauses — 4.4.5, 6.2.7, 7.3.6, 12.2.4, item e); data source — heritage protection authorities, Rosreestr; periodicity — annually.

B.1.5.3 Number of CHOs information on the investment readiness of which is available in open information resources; unit of measurement — units; level — O; target fields — AT; link to clauses — 4.4.5, 9.5.3, 11.6.7, 12.2.4, item e); data source — information system, open resources; periodicity — annually.

B.1.5.4 Volume of private investment attracted into heritage objects; unit of measurement — million RUB; level — C; target fields — AT; link to clauses — 4.4.5, 9.8, 12.2.4, item e); data source — financial reporting, data of the project office; periodicity — annually.

B.1.6.1 Share of CHOs brought into economic use (adaptive use); unit of measurement — %; level — C; target fields — AT; link to clauses — 4.4.4, 9.5.1, 12.2.4, item f); data source — data of heritage protection authorities, information system; periodicity — annually.

B.1.6.2 Share of vacant (unused) CHOs; unit of measurement — %; level — C; target fields — AT, RES; link to clauses — 4.4.4, 12.2.4, item f); data source — data of heritage protection authorities, monitoring; periodicity — annually.

B.1.6.3 Share of CHOs accessible to the population (physical and information accessibility); unit of measurement — %; level — C; target fields — AT, WB; link to clauses — 4.2.5, 12.2.4, item f); data source — data of cultural institutions, monitoring; periodicity — annually.

B.1.6.4 Number of operating creative and cultural enterprises located in heritage objects; unit of measurement — units; level — C; target fields — AT, SOC; link to clauses — 4.4.4, 9.5.6, 12.2.4, item f); data source — data of LSGBs, enterprise registers; periodicity — annually.

B.1.7.1 Number of newly identified attributes of historical and cultural value over the period; unit of measurement — units; level — O; target fields — ENV; link to clauses — 4.3.10, 5.4.4, item a), 9.5.5, 12.2.4, item g); data source — research reports, heritage protection authorities; periodicity — annually.

B.1.7.2 Volume of advance historical and cultural studies carried out; unit of measurement — units / million RUB; level — O; target fields — ENV; link to clauses — 4.3.10, 5.4.4, item a), 12.2.4, item g); data source — reporting of the project office, data of the clients; periodicity — annually.

B.1.7.3 Number of newly identified cultural heritage objects over the period; unit of measurement — units; level — O; target fields — ENV; link to clauses — 4.3.10, 12.2.4, item g); data source — Unified state register of CHOs; periodicity — annually.

B.1.7.4 Degree of formalization of the status of the historic settlement (on the scale: 1 — fact of recognition; 2 — approved boundaries; 3 — approved subject of protection; 4 — established requirements for urban-planning regulations); unit of measurement — level (1–4); level — C; target fields — ENV; link to clauses — 5.1.2, 6.2.2, 7.3.7; data source — heritage protection authorities; periodicity — upon change.

B.2.1.1.1 Permanent population of the historic settlement; unit of measurement — persons; level — I; target fields — WB, AT; link to clauses — 6.4.1, 7.8.2; data source — Rosstat, EMISS; periodicity — annually.

B.2.1.1.2 Population dynamics (increase / decrease); unit of measurement — %; level — I; target fields — WB, RES; link to clauses — 6.4.1, 7.8.2; data source — Rosstat, EMISS; periodicity — annually.

B.2.1.1.3 Migration balance (inflow minus outflow); unit of measurement — persons/year; level — I; target fields — AT, WB; link to clauses — 6.4.1, 7.8.2; data source — Rosstat, territorial bodies of the Ministry of Internal Affairs; periodicity — annually.

B.2.1.1.4 Share of the population of working age; unit of measurement — %; level — I; target fields — WB, RES; link to clauses — 6.4.1; data source — Rosstat; periodicity — annually.

*B.2.1.2 Quality of life and satisfaction*

B.2.1.2.1 Residents' satisfaction with the quality of the living environment; unit of measurement — points / %; level — I; target fields — WB, AT; link to clauses — 6.4.5, 7.5.4, 12.3.6; data source — sociological surveys; periodicity — annually.

B.2.1.2.2 Residents' satisfaction with the activity of governing bodies; unit of measurement — points / %; level — I; target fields — WB; link to clauses — 6.4.5, 12.2.7; data source — sociological surveys; periodicity — annually.

B.2.1.2.3 Housing provision of the population; unit of measurement — m²/person; level — C; target fields — WB; link to clauses — 6.4.5; data source — Rosstat; periodicity — annually.

B.2.1.2.4 Level of safety (number of registered offences); unit of measurement — units per 1 000 persons; level — I; target fields — WB, RES; link to clauses — 5.4.5, item d), 5.4.5, item i); data source — Ministry of Internal Affairs, territorial bodies; periodicity — annually.

*B.2.1.3 Social cohesion and identity*

B.2.1.3.1 Level of residents' perception of identity and of a sense of belonging to the territory; unit of measurement — points (survey); level — I; target fields — SOC, AT; link to clauses — 4.2.3, 5.4.3, item e), 6.4.2, 7.2.3; data source — sociological surveys; periodicity — once every 3–5 years.

B.2.1.3.2 Level of residents' perception of the authenticity of the historic environment; unit of measurement — points (survey); level — I; target fields — SOC, ENV; link to clauses — 4.3.2, 6.4.2, 7.2.3, 12.4.2; data source — sociological surveys; periodicity — once every 3–5 years.

B.2.1.3.3 Number of operating public organizations and NPOs in the field of heritage; unit of measurement — units; level — C; target fields — SOC; link to clauses — 5.2.1, 12.2.6; data source — register of NPOs, data of LSGBs; periodicity — annually.

B.2.1.3.4 Number of cultural events in the field of heritage per year; unit of measurement — units; level — O; target fields — SOC, AT; link to clauses — 6.4.6, 5.4.5, item e); data source — data of cultural institutions, LSGBs; periodicity — annually.

*B.2.1.4 Education and development of competence*

B.2.1.4.1 Number of educational programmes in the field of heritage and sustainable development; unit of measurement — units; level — O; target fields — WB, SOC; link to clauses — 4.2.1, 5.4.5, item b), 9.3.1, item e); data source — data of educational institutions; periodicity — annually.

B.2.1.4.2 Number of participants in educational and awareness programmes on heritage per year; unit of measurement — persons; level — O; target fields — WB, SOC; link to clauses — 4.2.1, 5.4.5, item b), 9.3.1, item e), 12.2.6; data source — data of educational institutions, of the project office; periodicity — annually.

B.2.1.4.3 Number of specialists in the field of restoration and preservation of heritage on the territory; unit of measurement — persons; level — C; target fields — ENV, WB; link to clauses — 6.4.6, 7.5.5, 10.3.6, item a); data source — data of SROs, educational institutions; periodicity — annually.

*B.2.1.5 Accessibility of social infrastructure*

B.2.1.5.1 Provision of education facilities relative to the standards; unit of measurement — %; level — C; target fields — WB; link to clauses — 5.4.5, item j), 6.3.5; data source — GISOGD, data of LSGBs, Rosstat; periodicity — annually.

B.2.1.5.2 Provision of healthcare facilities relative to the standards; unit of measurement — %; level — C; target fields — WB; link to clauses — 5.4.5, item j), 6.3.5; data source — GISOGD, data of LSGBs, Rosstat; periodicity — annually.

B.2.1.5.3 Provision of cultural facilities relative to the standards; unit of measurement — %; level — C; target fields — WB, SOC; link to clauses — 5.4.5, item j), 6.3.5, 6.4.6; data source — GISOGD, data of LSGBs; periodicity — annually.

B.2.1.5.4 Provision of sports and recreation facilities relative to the standards; unit of measurement — %; level — C; target fields — WB; link to clauses — 5.4.5, item j), 6.3.5; data source — GISOGD, data of LSGBs; periodicity — annually.

B.2.1.5.5 Share of the population with access to social infrastructure facilities within the standard walking or transport accessibility; unit of measurement — %; level — C; target fields — WB; link to clauses — 5.4.5, item j), 11.6.5, item b); data source — GIS analysis, and, where available, the digital twin; periodicity — annually.

*B.2.1.6 Displacement, gentrification and a tourism single function*

B.2.1.6.1 Migration outflow of the permanent population from the territory of the historic settlement (risk of displacement of residents); unit of measurement — persons/year; level — I; target fields — WB, SOC; link to clauses — 4.2.5, 5.4.4, item i), 4.3.11; data source — Rosstat, territorial bodies of the Ministry of Internal Affairs; periodicity — annually.

B.2.1.6.2 Increase in the cost of housing on the territory of the historic settlement relative to the municipal average (risk of gentrification); unit of measurement — %; level — C; target fields — WB, SOC; link to clauses — 4.2.5, 5.4.4, item i); data source — Rosstat, Rosreestr, data of LSGBs; periodicity — annually.

B.2.1.6.3 Share of the tourism function in the use of objects of the historic environment (risk of a single function); unit of measurement — %; level — C; target fields — RES, AT; link to clauses — 4.3.11, 5.4.4, item i); data source — data of LSGBs, expert survey; periodicity — annually.

B.2.2.1.1 Volume of the gross product of the territory (municipality); unit of measurement – million RUB; level – impact; target directions – attractiveness; link to clauses – 6.5.1, 7.5.1; data source – Federal State Statistics Service (Rosstat), Unified Interdepartmental Information and Statistical System (EMISS); periodicity – annually.

B.2.2.1.2 Unemployment rate; unit of measurement – %; level – impact; target directions – well-being, attractiveness; link to clauses – 6.5.1, 7.5.1; data source – Rosstat, employment service; periodicity – annually.

B.2.2.1.3 Average per capita income of the population; unit of measurement – RUB/month; level – impact; target directions – well-being; link to clauses – 6.5.1, 7.5.1; data source – Rosstat; periodicity – annually.

B.2.2.1.4 Number of small and medium-sized enterprises; unit of measurement – units; level – outcome; target directions – attractiveness; link to clauses – 6.5.1, 7.5.1; data source – Federal Tax Service (FTS), Unified Register of Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises; periodicity – annually.

B.2.2.1.5 Volume of investment in fixed capital; unit of measurement – million RUB; level – outcome; target directions – attractiveness; link to clauses – 6.5.1, 9.8; data source – Rosstat; periodicity – annually.

B.2.2.1.6 Average price of residential real estate in the territory of the historic settlement; unit of measurement – RUB/m²; level – impact; target directions – attractiveness; link to clauses – 4.4.6, 7.5.1; data source – Federal Service for State Registration, Cadastre and Cartography (Rosreestr), analytical market data; periodicity – annually.

*B.2.2.2 Tourism and visitation*

B.2.2.2.1 Number of tourists (visitors) per year; unit of measurement – persons; level – outcome; target directions – attractiveness; link to clauses – 6.5.4, 7.5.3, 12.4.6; data source – Ministry of Economic Development of the Russian Federation, data of accommodation facilities, mobile data operators; periodicity – annually.

B.2.2.2.2 Average annual occupancy of collective accommodation facilities; unit of measurement – %; level – outcome; target directions – attractiveness; link to clauses – 6.5.4, 7.5.3; data source – Rosstat, data of accommodation facilities; periodicity – annually.

B.2.2.2.3 Income from heritage-related tourism; unit of measurement – million RUB; level – outcome; target directions – attractiveness; link to clauses – 6.5.2, 7.5.3; data source – data of local self-government bodies, Rosstat; periodicity – annually.

B.2.2.2.4 Tourism load index (ratio of the number of tourists to the permanent population); unit of measurement – coefficient; level – outcome; target directions – resilience, preservation and improvement of the environment; link to clauses – 7.5.3, 12.4.6; data source – calculated (B.2.2.2.1 / B.2.1.1.1); periodicity – annually.

B.2.2.2.5 Coefficient of seasonal unevenness of the tourist flow; unit of measurement – coefficient; level – outcome; target directions – resilience, attractiveness; link to clauses – 6.5.4, 7.5.3, 12.4.6; data source – data of accommodation facilities, mobile data operators; periodicity – annually.

*B.2.2.3 Creative and cultural industries*

B.2.2.3.1 Number of enterprises of the creative and cultural industries; unit of measurement – units; level – outcome; target directions – attractiveness, social cohesion; link to clauses – 4.4.4, 6.4.6, 7.5.5; data source – FTS, registers of enterprises, data of local self-government bodies; periodicity – annually.

B.2.2.3.2 Number of persons employed in the creative and cultural industries; unit of measurement – persons; level – outcome; target directions – attractiveness, well-being; link to clauses – 4.4.4, 6.4.6, 7.5.5; data source – Rosstat, data of local self-government bodies; periodicity – annually.

B.2.2.3.3 Share of creative industries in the gross product of the territory; unit of measurement – %; level – impact; target directions – attractiveness; link to clauses – 4.4.4, 5.4.5, item c); data source – calculated; periodicity – once every 3–5 years.

*B.2.2.4 Budget indicators and heritage financing*

B.2.2.4.1 Local budget revenues; unit of measurement – million RUB; level – outcome; target directions – resilience; link to clauses – 6.5.5, 7.5.6, 10.3.4; data source – Electronic Budget, data of local self-government bodies; periodicity – annually.

B.2.2.4.2 Budget expenditure on the preservation of cultural heritage; unit of measurement – million RUB; level – output; target directions – preservation and improvement of the environment; link to clauses – 6.5.5, 7.5.6; data source – Electronic Budget, data of local self-government bodies; periodicity – annually.

B.2.2.4.3 Share of expenditure on heritage in total budget expenditure; unit of measurement – %; level – output; target directions – preservation and improvement of the environment; link to clauses – 6.5.5, 7.5.6; data source – calculated (B.2.2.4.2 / budget expenditure); periodicity – annually.

B.2.2.4.4 Volume of extrabudgetary financing raised for sustainable development measures; unit of measurement – million RUB; level – output; target directions – attractiveness, resilience; link to clauses – 9.8.2, 10.3.3; data source – data of the project office; periodicity – annually.

*B.2.2.5 Infrastructure provision*

B.2.2.5.1 Average wear of engineering networks (water supply, wastewater disposal, heat supply, electricity supply); unit of measurement – %; level – outcome; target directions – resilience, well-being; link to clauses – 6.3.5, 7.4.4, 4.1.4; data source – data of resource-supplying organizations, state information system for urban-planning activity (GISOGD); periodicity – annually.

B.2.2.5.2 Length of engineering networks modernized during the reporting period; unit of measurement – km; level – output; target directions – resilience; link to clauses – 6.3.5, 9.3.1, item a); data source – data of resource-supplying organizations; periodicity – annually.

B.2.2.5.3 Share of the territory provided with pedestrian and cycling infrastructure; unit of measurement – %; level – outcome; target directions – well-being, attractiveness; link to clauses – 6.3.5, 5.4.5, item j); data source – geographic information system (GIS) analysis, GISOGD; periodicity – annually.

B.2.2.5.4 Assessment of the transport connectivity of the territory of the historic settlement; unit of measurement – points / min; level – outcome; target directions – attractiveness, well-being; link to clauses – 5.4.5, item j), 11.6.5, item c); data source – digital twin, GIS analysis; periodicity – annually.

B.2.3.1.1 Area of green spaces for public use per inhabitant; unit of measurement – m²/person; level – outcome; target directions – preservation and improvement of the environment, well-being; link to clauses – 6.6.1, 7.6.1, 5.4.3, item b); data source – Rosstat, GIS data, GISOGD; periodicity – annually.

B.2.3.1.2 Share of planted areas in the total area of the territory of the historic settlement; unit of measurement – %; level – outcome; target directions – preservation and improvement of the environment; link to clauses – 6.6.1, 7.6.1; data source – GIS analysis; periodicity – annually.

B.2.3.1.3 Area of specially protected natural areas within the territory and in the zone of influence; unit of measurement – ha; level – outcome; target directions – preservation and improvement of the environment, responsible use of resources; link to clauses – 6.6.1, 5.4.5, item l); data source – Federal Service for Supervision of Natural Resources (Rosprirodnadzor), data of local self-government bodies; periodicity – once every 3–5 years.

B.2.3.1.4 Quality of water bodies in the territory of the historic settlement; unit of measurement – class / points; level – impact; target directions – preservation and improvement of the environment; link to clauses – 6.6.1, 7.6.1; data source – environmental monitoring data, Federal Service for Hydrometeorology and Environmental Monitoring (Roshydromet); periodicity – annually.

*B.2.3.2 Quality of the environment*

B.2.3.2.1 Ambient air quality (conformity with the maximum permissible concentrations (MPCs) for the main pollutants); unit of measurement – fractions of the MPC; level – impact; target directions – well-being, preservation and improvement of the environment; link to clauses – 6.6.2, 7.6.2; data source – Roshydromet, environmental monitoring data; periodicity – annually.

B.2.3.2.2 Noise pollution level in residential zones; unit of measurement – dB; level – outcome; target directions – well-being; link to clauses – 6.6.2, 7.6.2; data source – Federal Service for Surveillance on Consumer Rights Protection and Human Wellbeing (Rospotrebnadzor), monitoring data; periodicity – annually.

B.2.3.2.3 Area of recultivated and restored territories over the period; unit of measurement – ha; level – output; target directions – preservation and improvement of the environment, responsible use of resources; link to clauses – 7.6.1, 5.4.4, item f); data source – GIS data, data of local self-government bodies; periodicity – annually.

*B.2.3.3 Resilience of the territory and resource efficiency*

B.2.3.3.1 (recommended) Share of cultural heritage objects for which the climatic parameters of the territory are taken into account as a factor of the condition of the historic environment; unit of measurement – %; level – output; target directions – resilience, preservation and improvement of the environment; link to clauses – 6.6.3, 7.6.3; data source – data of the project office, cultural heritage protection authorities; periodicity – annually. Calculation of the indicator is not mandatory; a separate assessment of climate risks is not required (7.6.3).

B.2.3.3.2 (recommended) Share of the territory on which measures of resilience (adaptation) of the territory have been implemented; unit of measurement – %; level – outcome; target directions – resilience; link to clauses – 5.4.3, item c), 6.6.3, 7.6.3; data source – data of local self-government bodies, GIS analysis; periodicity – once every 3–5 years. Calculation of the indicator is not mandatory, and the indicator does not introduce separate mandatory climate requirements.

B.2.3.3.3 Water consumption per capita; unit of measurement – L/day; level – outcome; target directions – responsible use of resources; link to clauses – 6.6.4, 7.6.4, 5.4.3, item d); data source – Rosstat, resource-supplying organizations; periodicity – annually.

B.2.3.3.4 Energy consumption per capita; unit of measurement – kWh/year; level – outcome; target directions – responsible use of resources; link to clauses – 6.6.4, 7.6.4, 5.4.3, item d); data source – Rosstat, resource-supplying organizations; periodicity – annually.

B.2.3.3.5 Share of separately collected waste; unit of measurement – %; level – outcome; target directions – responsible use of resources; link to clauses – 6.6.4, 5.4.3, item d); data source – regional operator for the management of municipal solid waste (MSW); periodicity – annually.

B.2.4.1 Number of formats of participation of interested parties conducted (consultations, surveys, joint development of decisions) during the reporting period; unit of measurement – units; level – output; target directions – social cohesion; link to clauses – 4.2.4, 5.2, 8.8, 9.11, 12.2.6, 12.3.6; data source – reporting of the project office, minutes; periodicity – annually.

B.2.4.2 Number of participants in processes of engagement of interested parties during the period; unit of measurement – persons; level – output; target directions – social cohesion; link to clauses – 4.2.4, 12.2.6, 12.3.6; data source – reporting of the project office, minutes; periodicity – annually.

B.2.4.3 Number of comments and proposals received from interested parties; unit of measurement – units; level – output; target directions – social cohesion; link to clauses – 10.4.6, 11.5.1, 12.2.6; data source – register of submissions (11.5.1); periodicity – annually.

B.2.4.4 Share of proposals of interested parties considered and taken into account; unit of measurement – %; level – outcome; target directions – social cohesion; link to clauses – 10.4.6, 11.5.1, 12.2.6; data source – register of submissions, minutes of decisions; periodicity – annually.

B.2.4.5 Satisfaction of interested parties with participation processes; unit of measurement – points (survey); level – impact; target directions – social cohesion; link to clauses – 4.2.4, 12.2.6; data source – sociological surveys; periodicity – annually.

B.2.4.6 Number of participants in programs for the development of competence in the field of heritage and sustainable development; unit of measurement – persons; level – output; target directions – social cohesion, well-being; link to clauses – 4.2.1, 4.2.4, 5.2.3, 9.3.1, item e), 12.2.6; data source – data of the project office, educational institutions; periodicity – annually.

B.2.5.1 Compliance with the conditions of the minimum configuration of the implementation management system and the monitoring system (11.1.4 and 12.1.7); unit of measurement – yes/no for each condition: coordination of protection and development (4.5.4); participation of interested parties (4.2.4, 12.3.6); requirements for the preservation of heritage (11.7, 12.4); traceability (11.8.2, 12.8.2); linkage of indicators to objectives (5.7.3); level – outcome; target directions – all; link to clauses – 7.7.3, 11.1.4, 12.1.7, 12.2.7; data source – regulations on the management system, reporting of the implementation coordinating body; periodicity – annually.

B.2.5.2 Functioning of the project office (existence, regularity of meetings, share of decisions implemented); unit of measurement – yes/no; %; level – output; target directions – all; link to clauses – 11.2.1, 12.2.7; data source – minutes of the project office; periodicity – quarterly.

B.2.5.3 Share of measures of the implementation plan completed on time; unit of measurement – %; level – output; target directions – all; link to clauses – 10.1.2, 10.4.8, 12.2.7; data source – reporting of the project office; periodicity – quarterly.

B.2.5.4 Share of measures of the implementation plan with financing utilized in accordance with the plan; unit of measurement – %; level – output; target directions – all; link to clauses – 10.3, 11.3.4, 12.2.7; data source – budget control data; periodicity – quarterly.

B.2.5.5 Existence and level of functionality of the information system; unit of measurement – level (0–5: 0 – absent, 5 – full configuration of 11.6.1–11.6.3); level – outcome; target directions – all; link to clauses – 11.6, 12.1.5, 12.2.7; data source – operational documentation of the information system; periodicity – annually.

B.2.5.6 Publication of data on the progress of implementation in open access; unit of measurement – yes/no; periodicity; level – output; target directions – all; link to clauses – 11.6.8, 12.5.5, 12.2.7; data source – open information resources; periodicity – annually.

B.2.5.7 Number of independent assessments of the implementation of measures during the reporting period; unit of measurement – units; level – output; target directions – preservation and improvement of the environment; link to clauses – 7.12, 12.5.3, 12.2.7; data source – assessment minutes, reporting of the implementation coordinating body; periodicity – annually.

B.3.1.1 Indicators of this annex are intended for establishing the baseline (6.1.2, 7.1.6), monitoring the achievement of sustainable development objectives (Clause 12) and assessing the effectiveness of measures (12.5). The specific list of indicators and their target values are determined when the sustainable development documentation of a specific historic settlement is developed, taking into account its specific features, the degree of formalization of the status (5.1.2) and the configuration of the monitoring system (12.1.7). A minimum set of indicators may be used, with subsequent expansion as the monitoring system develops (12.1.7).

B.3.1.2 For each indicator, an indicator passport is formed containing the following particulars:

- indicator code – the code designation under this annex (for example, B.1.1.1); - name – the full name of the indicator; - unit of measurement – the unit of measurement of the indicator value; - level – output / outcome / impact; - direction – person and community / environment and heritage / heritage economy / management (12.2.2); - target direction – one or more of the six basic objectives (5.4.3); - link to the directions of iterative analysis – one or more directions of 5.4.5; - link to the clauses of the standard – the clauses of this standard to which the indicator is linked; - baseline value – the value at the time the baseline is established, the date of recording; - territorial level of calculation – municipality, settlement (inhabited locality), territory of the historic settlement, territorial unit under Annex C (C.4.4), or object; - target value (up to and including 3 years) – the target value for the short-term horizon; - target value (more than 3 years and up to and including 6 years) – the target value for the medium-term horizon; - target value (more than 6 years) – the target value for the long-term horizon; - periodicity of measurement – the recommended periodicity of data collection; - data source – the specific data source for the calculation; - calculation method – the formula or a description of the calculation method; - for indicators whose source is a survey: the wording of the question, the population, the sampling method and the rule for converting the answer into the unit of measurement; - for expert scales of 0–5: a brief rubric (0 – absent, 5 – full conformity); - responsible person – the person responsible for data collection and calculation.

Quantitative assessment is applied alongside historical and cultural analysis and expert assessment. Such assessment does not replace the state historical and cultural expert review (4.3.6).

B.3.1.3 For the list of measures for implementation of the master plan in respect of the territory of the historic settlement, a core set of indicators should be used: B.1.1.1, B.1.1.3, B.1.3.5, B.1.6.1, B.1.6.2, B.1.7.4, B.2.1.2.1. The core set does not replace the list of indicators of the specific historic settlement (B.3.1.1). The indicators of the core set are calculated for the territory of the historic settlement; if data are not available, the level of calculation is indicated in the passport (B.3.1.2, 5.3.1).

B.3.2.1 Share indicators (percentage indicators) are calculated by the formula:

P = (N_act / N_tot) × 100 %,

where N_act is the number of objects (elements, territories) that meet the specified criterion; N_tot is the total number of objects (elements, territories) in the set under consideration.

B.3.2.2 The authenticity index of the historic environment (B.1.2.1) is calculated as a weighted average expert assessment on the six authenticity parameters (3.1.8):

I_auth = Σ(w_i × S_i) / Σ(w_i),

where S_i is the expert assessment for the i-th authenticity parameter (on a scale from 0 to 100 points); w_i is the weighting coefficient of the i-th parameter, determined by expert judgment taking into account the specific features of the historic settlement; i = 1…6 (parameters: form and construction; materials and substance; use and function; traditions and techniques; location and setting; spirit and feeling of the place). The assessment is carried out by a group of at least three independent experts; the final value is determined as the arithmetic mean of the individual assessments. The assessment methodology is based on the Operational Guidelines for the Implementation of the World Heritage Convention (paragraph 82).

B.3.2.3 The integrity index of the historic environment (B.1.2.2) is calculated as a weighted average expert assessment on the integrity parameters (3.1.9):

I_int = Σ(w_j × S_j) / Σ(w_j),

where S_j is the expert assessment for the j-th integrity parameter (on a scale from 0 to 100 points); w_j is the weighting coefficient of the j-th parameter; the parameters include: completeness (presence of all elements necessary to express the historical and cultural value); sufficiency of the size of the territory to represent the significant characteristics; absence of adverse effects of development or neglect. The methodology is based on the Operational Guidelines for the Implementation of the World Heritage Convention (paragraph 88).

B.3.2.4 The tourism load index (B.2.2.2.4) is calculated as:

I_tour = N_tour / N_pop,

where N_tour is the number of tourists (visitors) per year (B.2.2.2.1); N_pop is the permanent population (B.2.1.1.1). An index value greater than 1.0 indicates a potentially high tourism load that requires an assessment of the impact on heritage and the historic environment (12.4.6).

B.3.2.5 The coefficient of seasonal unevenness of the tourist flow (B.2.2.2.5) is calculated as:

K_seas = N_max_month / (N_tour / 12),

where N_max_month is the number of tourists in the peak-season month; N_tour is the total number of tourists per year. A coefficient value close to 1.0 indicates an even distribution of the flow; values above 3.0 indicate pronounced seasonality.

B.3.2.6 The indicators of preservation of elements of the subject of protection by analytical groups (B.1.3.1–B.1.3.4) are calculated by the formula in B.3.2.1, where N_act is the number of preserved elements recorded in the subject of protection and confirmed by expert examination; N_tot is the total number of elements of the approved subject of protection of the historic settlement assigned to the corresponding analytical group. The list of elements is determined on the basis of the approved subject of protection according to the composition in 6.2.3 (clause 2 of Article 59 of Federal Law No. 73-FZ of 25 June 2002 "On cultural heritage objects (monuments of history and culture) of the peoples of the Russian Federation" [1]) and inventory data. The analytical groups B.1.3 are not the composition of the subject of protection.

B.3.3.1 Data sources for the calculation of monitoring indicators are determined in accordance with 12.3.1 and include:

a) official statistical data – Rosstat, EMISS, departmental statistics;

b) data of information systems – GISOGD, the federal state information system for territorial planning (FGIS TP), the federal state information system "Unified Digital Platform 'National Spatial Data System'" (FGIS ETsP NSPD), the state integrated information system for public finance management "Electronic Budget";

c) data of the Unified State Register of Cultural Heritage Objects (monuments of history and culture) of the peoples of the Russian Federation;

d) data of geographic information layers (11.6.3);

e) where a territorial digital twin is available — data of the territorial digital twin (11.6.5);

f) data of passports and digital passports of cultural heritage objects (11.6.7, item a);

g) results of sociological surveys and consultations with interested parties, including through the service for collecting opinions and proposals (11.6.5, item f));

h) results of expert examinations and of the independent assessment of the implementation of measures (12.5.3);

i) environmental monitoring data (Roshydromet, Rospotrebnadzor, Rosprirodnadzor);

j) data of Rosreestr and of the Unified State Register of Real Estate;

k) data of resource-supplying organizations and of regional operators for the management of MSW;

l) data of the FTS and of the Unified Register of Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises.

B.3.3.2 For each indicator, the specific data source is indicated in the passport. If data cannot be obtained from the specified source, alternative sources may be used, with an indication of the justification for the substitution and an assessment of the degree of reliability (by analogy with 6.1.1).

B.3.4.1 The recommended minimum periodicity of data collection is determined by the level of the indicator (12.3.2):

a) output indicators – quarterly;

b) outcome indicators – annually;

c) impact indicators – once every 3–5 years.

B.3.4.2 For indicators whose data are generated in an automated mode through the information system (11.6), data may be collected more frequently.

B.3.4.3 The periodicity of the comprehensive assessment of the achievement of sustainable development objectives is aligned with the horizons of strategic planning documents (10.2.6) and with the periodicity of comprehensive monitoring reports (12.5.4, item b). In mode A, the periodicity is also aligned with reporting on the implementation of the master plan (12.5.4).

B.3.5.1 Correspondence of the indicators of this annex with the standardized indicators (12.2.5) is informative in character. This standard does not require calculation of the full set of indicators of GOST R ISO 37120 [6], GOST R ISO 37122 and GOST R ISO 37123. For informative correspondence:

a) GOST R ISO 37120 [6] (Sustainable cities and communities — Indicators for city services and quality of life) – indicators of groups B.2.1 (social), B.2.2 (economic) and B.2.3 (environmental) may correspond to the profile and supporting indicators of that standard (demography, employment, infrastructure provision, quality of the environment, education, safety);

b) GOST R ISO 37122 (Sustainable cities and communities — Indicators for smart cities) – indicators of digitalization and of the information system (B.2.5.5, B.2.5.6) may correspond to the indicators of that standard;

c) GOST R ISO 37123 (Sustainable cities and communities — Indicators for resilient cities) – the recommended indicators of resilience and adaptation of the territory (B.2.3.3.1, B.2.3.3.2) and other resilience indicators may correspond to the indicators of that standard;

d) GOST R 59124-2020 (Preservation of cultural heritage objects — Composition and content of the scientific and design documentation of a protection-zone design) – indicators of landscape and visual analysis (B.1.2.4) and of the condition of elements of the subject of protection (B.1.3) may correspond to that standard;

e) the UN Sustainable Development Goals – indicators of this annex may correspond to the indicators of Goal 11 (Sustainable cities and settlements), in particular to target 11.4 (intensifying efforts to protect and preserve the world's cultural and natural heritage).

B.3.5.2 Informative correspondence with the standardized indicators may be used for comparative analysis with similar territories (7.8.4). When the system of indicators of a specific historic settlement is formed, a correspondence table of the selected indicators of this annex and the indicators of GOST R ISO 37120 [6], GOST R ISO 37122 and GOST R ISO 37123, indicating the codes of the corresponding indicators, should be drawn up (this is not an obligation). The full set of indicators of those standards is not included in the mandatory set of monitoring.